A Lesson on Conformity from Michael Taylor

          In Black Swan Green, arguably one of the most prominent themes in the novel is Jason's love for poetry and his journey with his alter ego "Eliot Bolivar". Bolivar represents many of Jason's internal struggles, his inability in his family, his insecurity with his self-image, and his self-expression. Jason writes under this pseudonym under the fear that his secret would be discovered and revealed to the world, for that he could never socially recover. His double life leads him on an interesting and almost fairytale-esque journey where he encounters a woman by the name of Eva van Outryve de Crommelynck, who transforms into a sort of mentor for him and a parental figure he so desperately needs. I believe that Jason formed his societal ideals not only from peer pressure but also from his desire to appeal to his father. The parallels between them are uncanny, allowing Jason to grow out of his toxic mindset on himself and others. 

    Jason's family is first introduced in the first pages, where Jason highlights their inability and coldness to one another, particularly speaking about his father. We see Jason struggle with his own self-image throughout the novel, with the ridicule he faces at school, and he channels that hurt into his poetry as a place where he can truly be himself without the fear of being bullied. In meeting Eva in the chapter "Solarium", he is met with something he has never encountered before: authenticity and self-awareness. She inquires about his choice of wording for his pseudonym as she points out how if he chooses to express himself, he should be proud of that, not concealing from society. More bluntly, this relationship significantly contrasts with his relationship with his father, the main relationship that is meaningful to him. With his father, Jason internalizes the mentality to shield sensitivity and become a beacon of masculinity as he sees his father. His desire to conform directly comes from his father's approval. Jason's need to conform slowly breaks down as we see his father's image slip in chapter eight, "Souvenirs," where Jason bluntly sees his father's personality flip when they encounter his boss, Craig Salt. Jason is disgusted and frankly shocked seeing his father's actions and the fake persona he adopts to impress his boss and fit into the social hierarchy of being an adult in a corporation. Even with his efforts, his father lost his job in the end. Which begs the question to Jason, does it even matter if I fit the social hierarchy if living my whole life to fit into it just knocks me down time and time again? 

    The parallels between the two men are striking, but also serve as a moment of growth for Jason's character and score as one of the central themes under the coming-of-age theme at the heart of this story. Jason finally stands up to the boys at school by smashing a calculator and snitching to a teacher about the horrific acts done by his tormentors. Instead of being in fear of retaliation, we see him come to terms with living apart from the social hierarchy he has centered his life around. With his view of his father now crushed as he is revealed to have an affair and tears the family even farther apart, Jason now looks back on the life he once lived with sorrow but he is finally able to live a life without hiding himself or his identity,  or for the approval of his peers or the approval of his father.



Comments

  1. It's interesting--and appropriate--that you contrast Eva's directness, authenticity, and self-awareness with Jason's father's general mode around the house. It's true that Jason has never encountered anyone like Eva before, and that she becomes a kind of mentor in a quasi-parental way. But she is an *artistic* mentor, who flatters Jason by calling his juvenile efforts "work" and taking them seriously, giving them tough love. In contrast, we see Michael mostly being concerned with "being right" in his arguments with Helena, and I also recall Jason's devastating characterization of how his dad "snips and snips" at him in his interrogations, not letting Jason off the hook.

    Eva too could be said to "snip and snip"--especially when she's grilling him about his "gay poetry" and the "Hairy Barbarians"--and Jason DOES stammer with her the way he does with his father. He's understandably nervous around her! But her criticism, ironically, seems to come more from a place of love (tough love!) than his own father's does. She tries to get Jason to "improve" his poetry, to make it more honest and direct. Michael, in contrast, gets the same face when Jason stammers as he has when he learns his new drill is missing a part. Jason doesn't feel "defective" around Eva--she pushes him to improve in ways he CAN improve. The contrast does not speak well for Mr. Taylor.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Emmie, I agree with the saying that Jason's fear of self expression/embracing his authenticity. When he sees his father act all fake to impress Mr. Salt, he understands why Eva was so blunt. He was very much disgusted by his father and he didn't want to be like that. Even though Eva only shows up for one chapter, I think she is very important in sort of "guiding" Jason away from becoming his father.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Emmie, you bring up an interesting point about these mentors in Jason's life. I think mentors shape who you are (especially your family) and it seems like in the beginning Jason was desperately searching his father's validation. Meeting Eva showed him a different type of adult that would respect him, and I agree that Eva really helped Jason come to age with himself and his writing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Emmie! I agree with how you compared two of Jason's parental figures/mentors, his father and Eva, and showed how they represent different paths he could go on. Having a mentor that's a positive influence is something that's seen often in coming of age narratives, and an important part of them, so I like that you brought it up. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Emmie! Both me and Ruby think that your blog topic is super intriguing! I agree with you that Jason hesitates when it comes to how he presents himself. He already doesn't share his poetry (and by the end of the book he never does) but the parts of himself that either get found out or are shared only cause him trouble. No wonder conformity is pushed onto him! I really liked your blog you made great points!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree that Jason's father is one of the most influential characters in this book. Many of Jason's behaviours are reflective of his fathers and it truly feels like he inherited his fathers obsession with others. Yet due to the reflectiveness of these behaviors, Jason is able to look at himself through a mirror. And by watching his father's unsavory actions, Jason is able to see flaws within himself and develop.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jason and his dad are quite similar in the earlier parts of the book, but it's Jason's realization that Michael has some very bad behaviors that motivates Jason to criticize his dad and realign himself with the people he values more deeply. More and more often Jason finds himself questioning the hierarchy and social requirements in Black Swan Green, and seeing it represented in his dad makes him see it as unpleasant.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Emmie, this is a great analysis of Jason's character development and his relationship with his dad throughout the story. It's definitely true that the way each of their personalities and self-awareness develop is significant in Jason's coming of age. His constant struggle for approval is a constant battle that his views on change over time.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts